American Academy of Pediatrics
Home
Parenting Corner
Children's Health Topics
Bookstore and Publications
Professional Education and Resources
Advocacy
Member Center
About AAP
 
News Room
Sitemap
Contact Us

Search: 








Child Abuse CA) Suspicion and Reporting Among Primary Care Practitioners (PCPs)

Emalee G Flaherty, MD 1, Robert Sege, MD, PhD 2, Niramol Dhepyasuwan, MEd 3, Lori L Price, MS 2, Richard Wasserman, MD, MPH 4 and A report from the PROS network 3. 1 Pediatrics, Children's Memorial Hospital/NUMS, Chicago, IL, United States, 60614; 2 Pediatrics, Floating Hospital for Children, Boston, MA, United States, 02111; 3 PROS, American Academy of Pediatrics, Elk Grove Village, IL, United States, 60007 and 4 Pediatrics, U of Vermont, Burlington, VT, United States, 05401.

Background: Relatively few cases of CA are reported from primary care settings. The paucity of reports may result if CA is rarely seen in primary care, if CA is seen but not recognized, or if seen and recognized but not reported.

Objective: 1) To determine frequency of suspicion for CA among PCPs. 2) To examine the association between level of suspicion and practitioner reports made to child protective services (CPS).

Design/Methods: 424 Pediatric Research in Office Setting (PROS) Network PCPs each collected information about 40 consecutive children having an injury (injury defined as one worthy of notation in the chart, suspected sexual abuse excluded). PCPs indicated their suspicion that injury was caused by CA on a Likert scale (Very Unlikely, Unlikely, Possible, Likely, Very Likely). They were also asked if they had reported suspected abuse (Yes or No) to CPS.

Results: The results of 14,023 office-based injury visits were analyzed. After excluding 65 (0.5%) injuries previously reported to CPS, PCPs suspected that 87 (0.6%) of the injuries were likely or very likely to have been caused by abuse. They reported 51 (58.6%) of these suspicious injuries to CPS. The median age of children reported to CPS was 3 years, younger than the median age of children not reported (8 years; p=0.0001). Those deemed very likely CA were less likely to be reported than those deemed likely CA.

Conclusions: The evidence is that abuse is suspected fairly frequently (1/160 injured children deemed likely or very likely abused). Children in this likely/very likely category were reported only slightly more than half the time to CPS. Research is being conducted that will describe how these unreported children are managed and the consequences of this high level of under-reporting.

Level of practitioner suspicion compared to decision to report to CPS

Level of suspicion

Very Unlikely # (%)

Unlikely # (%)

Possible # (%)

Likely # (%)

Very Likely # (%)

Children reported to CPS

2 (0.02)

7 (0.5)

35 (24.6)

24 (82.8)

27 (46.6)

Children not reported to CPS

12393 (99.9)

1327 (99.5)

107 (75.3)

5 (17.2)

31 (53.4)

 





©  COPYRIGHT AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Site Map | Contact Us | Privacy Statement | About Us | Home
American Academy of Pediatrics, 141 Northwest Point Blvd., Elk Grove Village, IL, 60007, 847-434-4000