
|

|
PERIODIC SURVEY OF FELLOWS
American Academy of Pediatrics
Division of Health Policy Research
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Periodic Survey #42
Providing Health Care to Adolescents:
Pediatricians' Attitudes and Practices
This report presents findings from Periodic Survey #42 on pediatricians’
current practices and attitudes regarding adolescent care, as well as
barriers to providing that care. The survey was initiated by the Section
on Adolescent Health. These finding will be used to help develop the content
of educational programs in adolescent health care and assist in efforts
to encourage residency programs to increase the amount of time in adolescent
health care training, as well as encourage insurers to improve coverage
for adolescent health care. The survey was conducted from November 1998
to February 1999; after five mailings a total of 943 completed questionnaires
were received for a response rate of 58.1%. These analyses are based on
responses from the 704 pediatricians who provide health supervision to
patients age 12 or older (this represents 96.4% of pediatricians who provide
health supervision).
Providing Health Care to Adolescents
- Tobacco use (77.9%)
- Drug/alcohol use (77.5%)
- School Issues (73.3%)
- Sexual activity/pregnancy prevention (72.7%)
- Exercise/physical fitness (59.2%)
- Nutrition/eating disorders (58.7%)
- STDs (56.6%)
Other topics such as seat belt use, mental health concerns, violence
prevention, sexual and physical abuse, and media issues are much less
frequently discussed with adolescent patients.
- Overall, pediatricians are fairly confident in their ability to assess
and manage common medical problems of adolescents. On a scale where
1=very confident and 5=not at all confident, the mean score for confidence
in assessing and managing medical problems is 1.5 and 1.4, respectively.
However, pediatricians are slightly less confident in their ability
to diagnose and manage gynecological problems (mean score: 2.8 and 2.9,
respectively) and psychosocial problems (2.5 and 2.8) of adolescents.
Barriers to Providing Health Care to Adolescents
- A large proportion of pediatricians named the following as barriers
to providing adolescent health care in their practice:
- Lack of training in gynecological and pregnancy care (56.9% of pediatricians
reporting)
- Infrequent follow-up/poor attendance (51.0%)
- Lack of adequate reimbursement for the time it takes to provide
care for adolescents (46.1%)
- Lack of interest in providing gynecological/pregnancy care (41.8%)
- Difficulty identifying where to refer adolescents for psychosocial
problems (39.9%)
- Lack of training in adolescent health problems (39.5%)
According to a majority of pediatricians, the following are not perceived
as barriers to adolescent health care in their practice: difficulties
identifying where to refer adolescents for subspecialty (medical) care
(68.4%), the inability to take on additional patients (66.6%), high medical
liability costs (64.5%), a lack of interest in adolescent health issues
(60.2%), and difficulties communicating with adolescents (55.6%).
For all of the listed potential barriers, many pediatricians (20%-30%)
are unsure as to whether these factors act as barriers to providing adolescent
care in their practice.
- Overall, pediatricians report more frequent barriers to providing
adolescent health care in managed care plans than in traditional (fee-for-service)
indemnity plans.
- 48.8% of pediatricians say they almost always receive inadequate
reimbursement for seeing adolescents in managed care plans compared
to 29.8% who say reimbursement from indemnity plans is almost always
inadequate.
- 34.3% of pediatricians say they almost always have difficulty referring
adolescents in managed care for a psychosocial problem; 18.9% say
this is almost always a problem in indemnity plans.
- Problems scheduling adequate time for adolescent visits are said
to be a barrier more frequently in managed care than in indemnity
plans: 30.1% and 21.4% of pediatricians reporting, respectively.
- Pediatricians identified the following as very effective in
reducing potential barriers to providing adolescent health care:
- Availability of clearly defined state statutes on confidentiality,
consent and other legal issues (61.4%)
- Statements regarding confidentiality, consent and ethics of adolescent
care by state medical boards, malpractice insurers, the AAP, etc.
(57.2%)
- Information on local resources for referral for adolescents’ medical
or psychosocial problems (54.4%)
- Training in the area of confidentiality, informed consent and ethical
decision-making at continuing medical education sessions (52.6%)
- Brochures and other printed material on adolescent health topics
for patient education (50.7%)
- Training on how to communicate effectively with adolescents (50.4%)
- Information on appropriate ICD-9 and CPT codes for adolescent-specific
care (49.9%)
Interest in Further Education in Adolescent Health
More than one-third of pediatricians (36.3%) are very interested in receiving
further education in the area of adolescent health, and 53.7% are somewhat
interested. These pediatricians identified AAP self-instructional material
(56.2%), local 2-day training courses (54.5%) and handbooks, guidelines
or other written materials (51.5%) as preferred ways to receive education
in adolescent health.
|

|

|