
|

|
PERIODIC SURVEY OF FELLOWS
American Academy of Pediatrics
Division of Health Policy Research
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Periodic Survey #55
Pediatricians Views on the Treatment & Prevention of
Violent Injuries to Children
This survey addressed issues surrounding the prevention and
treatment of injuries caused by community and domestic violence and child
abuse. The survey was initiated to compare data from a national sample of
members with data from members of the Pediatric Research in Office Settings
(PROS) network participating in two studies: The Child Abuse Reporting Experience
Study (CARES) and the Randomized Controlled Trial to Prevent Child Violence
(Safety Check). In addition, selected questions replicated those from a 1998
Periodic Survey on the prevention of violent injuries to children (PS#38)
to track trends in the reported number of violence-related injuries treated,
as well as the attitudes and behavior of pediatricians regarding counseling
on prevention of such injuries.
Periodic Survey #55 was an eight-page self-administered questionnaire
sent to 1,603 active United States members of the AAP from October 2002 through
May 2003. After an original and five follow-up mailings a total of 851 completed
questionnaires were received for a response rate of 53%. Analyses for the
2003 survey (PS#55) are based on 774 pediatricians who provide direct patient
care (91% of all respondents); data for the 1998 survey (PS#38) include 939
pediatricians indirect patient care (93% of all respondents).
I. REPORTS OF VIOLENCE-RELATED INJURIES
- Overall, in 2003 the proportion of pediatricians who report treating one
or more violence-related injury (an injury due to child abuse, domestic or
community violence) in the 12 months prior to the survey significantly increased
from that reported in 1998 (82% v 71%, p<.001). The proportion of pediatricians
who report treating each type of injury has increased:
| |
- 66% treated injuries from child abuse in 2003 compared to 54% in
1998, p<.001.
- 47% treated injuries from domestic violence in 2003 compared to
38% in 1998, p<.001.
- 65% treated injuries from community violence in 2003 compared to
41% in 1998, p<.001
|
-
In 2003, compared to 1998, significantly more pediatricians
in urban (but not inner city), suburban and rural areas report treating
each type of violent injury. Rural pediatricians report the sharpest increases:
90% in 2003 compared to 60% in 1998 report treating injuries due to child
abuse; 71% v 44% report domestic violence injuries and 77% v 36% report
injuries due to community violence (p<.001). Similar proportions of urban
inner city pediatricians in both survey years report treating injuries due
to child abuse and domestic violence; however, in 2003, the proportion that
report seeing cases of community violence has significantly increased (70%
in 2003 v 57% in 1998, p<.01).
| |
Percent of Pediatricians Reporting Injuries
Related to:
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Child Abuse
|
|
Domestic Violence
|
|
Community Violence
|
|
|
1998
|
|
2003
|
|
1998
|
|
2003
|
|
1998
|
|
2003
|
| Urban inner city |
67.3
|
|
71.7
|
|
48.4
|
|
43.7
|
|
56.5
|
|
70.4*
|
| Rural/Small town |
59.7
|
|
89.7
|
|
44.4
|
|
70.7
|
|
36.4
|
|
76.5
|
| Urban non-inner city |
51.1
|
|
65.4*
|
|
28.0
|
|
45.7*
|
|
35.0
|
|
62.4
|
| Suburban |
40.8
|
|
54.8*
|
|
31.0
|
|
44.1
|
|
33.7
|
|
60.3
|
|
* p<.01, for difference between survey years
|
| p<.001, for difference between survey
years |
II. ATTITUDES TOWARD PREVENTION OF VIOLENT INJURIES
-
In both survey years, nearly all pediatricians believe
they should screen for child abuse at regular health maintenance
visits, however, slightly fewer so stated in 2003 (90% in 2003 v
93% in 1998, p<.01). The proportion of pediatricians who believe
they should screen for other types of violence has significantly
increased from 1998: 72% in 2003 v 66% in 1998 believe they should
screen for domestic violence (p<.05) and 77% compared to 71%
think they should screen for community violence (p<.01).
|
-
In 2003, as in 1998, pediatricians express substantially
more confidence in their ability to identify children at risk for
and manage injuries due to child abuse than domestic violence and
community violence; however, reported confidence in the ability
to identify and treat victims of domestic and community violence
has increased from 1998:
|
| |
- In 2003, 43% of pediatricians say they are confident in their ability
to identify children at risk for domestic violence compared to 37%
in 1998 (p<.05) and 52% compared to 44% feel confident in their
ability to manage patients injured as a result of domestic violence
(p<.01).
- 41% in 2003 compared to 33% in 1998 are confident in their ability
to identify children at risk for community violence and 40% compared
to 33% are confident in their ability to advise children and parents
on interpersonal violence prevention strategies (p<.001 and p<.01,
respectively).
- Slightly fewer pediatricians in 2003 compared to 1998 say they are
confident in their ability to identify children at risk of injury
from child abuse (60% and 65%, p<.05); similar proportions in both
years report confidence in managing patients injured as a result of
child abuse (60% and 63%, n.s.).
|
-
In both survey years, considerably more pediatricians
feel they have had adequate professional training in the area of
child abuse than in domestic or community violence. About 50% of
pediatricians in both 2003 and 1998 feel their training in child
abuse was sufficient; however, 30% in 2003 compared to 21% in 1998
say they have had adequate training in domestic violence (p<.001)
and only 24% and 17% feel the same about their training in community
violence (p<.001).
|
-
Few pediatricians in both survey years think there
is sufficient time in health maintenance visits to address violence
prevention issues; however, while not directly comparable due to
question wording differences, more pediatricians appear to be making
the time in 2003 than in 1998. In 2003, 28% think there is sufficient
time to address [any] violence prevention issues in health maintenance
visits; in 1998, 17% thought there was sufficient time to address
child abuse issues, 16% community violence issues and only 13% said
there was time to address domestic violence issues
|
-
In 2003, about one-third of pediatricians (35%)
feel they adequately address violence prevention issues in their
practice, up from 29% in 1998 (p<.05). Yet nearly two-thirds
still feel they spend too little time on such issues (64% in 2003
v 71% in 1998).
|
-
In both survey years, about the same proportion
of pediatricians (38%) said they used the Injury Prevention Program
(TIPP) in their practice. Compared to 1998, more pediatricians in
2003 say they would be "very likely" to use an Academy
Violent Injury Prevention Program (VIPP) to aid in anticipatory
guidance on reducing violent injuries (41% in 2003 v 35% in 1998,
p<.05) and equal proportions in 2003 and 1998 (44%, 45%) say
they would be "somewhat likely" to do so.
|
American Academy of Pediatrics, Division of Health
Policy Research
Periodic Survey #55: Executive Summary
"Pediatricians Views on the Treatment & Prevention of Violent
Injuries to Children", January 2004
Not for citation or quotation without permission of the
author
|

|

|